Tyler's Trinkets NY
Mystery Polish - Prototypes & Overpours
Mystery Polish - Prototypes & Overpours
Out of stock
*This item is excluded from sales & coupons
Couldn't load pickup availability
Description
Description
Who doesn't love a little mystery? π§ Especially at a great price! π
We have 3 types of polishes that may be part of the mystery polishes:
- Prototypes - These are very limited quantity polishes that can be unreleased prototypes or variations/early formulas of current/previous polishes. Many prototypes only have 1 or 2 bottles!Β
- Oops! - These are polishes that were made in a batch, but didn't come out the way we expected. Maybe the color was slightly off, or the glitters sank too quickly. They are perfectly good polishes, just not what we were going for.
- Overpours - These are extras from exclusive sales (e.g. The Polish Nook, PPU, FB Customs, etc.) or previous collections that have been discontinued.Β
Mystery orders will contain any one of the above polishes based on stock and quantity ordered, and can include creams, specialty formulas, and toppers.Β *We will try to avoid duplicates. If you order multiple mystery polishes and we cannot avoid duplicates, we will contact you to either accept duplicates or refund the extras.
Note on Bottles:Β During prototyping we use a variety of polish bottles (mostly tester bottles from when we were sampling options for our permanent bottles). You will receive a polish that is at least 11ml (our current bottle size) but bottle shape and brush style may vary from our normal bottles!
Nail Polish Ingredients
Nail Polish Ingredients
Our nail polishes are hand-mixed in small batches using ingredients that are:
- Vegan
- Cruelty-free
- 10-Free
We are passionate about creating beautiful nail varnishes that contain no animal products or biproducts, are never tested on animals, and are free of 10+ potentially harmful ingredients that can often be found in cosmetics. For a full list of ingredients, click here.
If you would like the ingredient list for a specific product, please Contact Us so we can assist!
Manicure Tips & Tricks
Manicure Tips & Tricks
When it comes to applying nail polish, practice makes perfect! Check out the Nail Polish Info page for some tips and tricks to help you get the best at-home manicure using our Tyler's Trinkets polishes!
Disclaimers
Disclaimers
General Nail Polish Warnings:
- Nail polish can be flammable β Keep away from open flames
- Products are for external use only - DO NOT CONSUME
- Keep out of reach of children without supervision
- Should any irritation occur, discontinue use immediately
Product Color Disclaimer:
While every effort is made to ensure photos accurately depict each product, colors may vary slightly due to differences in lighting sources and monitor/screen settings.
AI-Modified Photos:
We may use artificial intelligence (AI) tools during the photo-editing process to:
- Remove distracting background objects
- Generate background images/scenery around the product
These tools are never used to alter or modify the products themselves, only the background/surroundings. All product photos are taken to represent the true product and editing is only done to correct lighting, remove blemishes (such as a piece of lint stuck to a bottle cap), and color-correct to match the true color.
Share

Tyler does not have to take requests for overpours, and it's considerate that he does. Plus, he always knows how to take your request and give you the perfect mystery polish! I got a beautiful glitter crelly from a previous collab and I'm obsessed with the glitter mix.
Would have picked one and not the other 3 but I am absolutely in love. I got 2 prototypes and 2 over-pours. All different finishes. Debating if its too soon to order more!
I got so lucky! I got a prototype magnetic polish - my first magnetic! I'm so happy with it.
Read my preferences and sent me an LE topper polish that has beautiful shreds. It's such a considerate thing to take someone's preferences into account for a mystery polish; Tyler doesn't have to do that but he does! β₯οΈ
I always love getting the Mystery Polishes- Iβve never been disappointed! I order one every time and have expanded my Tylerβs Trinkets collection- I love a good mystery!